From the Drums · 35 of 52

The fence

Plant security on the Houston Ship Channel changed after September 11, 2001. Federal port-security law (2002) and later chemical-facility rules added background-checked credentials for waterfront workers, cameras, vehicle barriers and slower gate checks. A refinery is guarded not because it is valuable but because of the supply chain that runs out from its gate — jet fuel, diesel, propane and the feedstock for medical plastics — to people who never see it.

osprey nest

There is a morning in the middle of September that most people over a certain age can place themselves in. They know where they were standing. They know who told them, or what screen they were looking at, or which radio was on in which truck. It was a Tuesday. The sky over the Northeast was the kind of clear that makes people say later that they remember the sky. Here on the bay it was hot, the way it is hot in September, and the plants were running, and by mid-morning everybody knew that something had happened in New York and in Washington and in a field in Pennsylvania, and that the day was not going to be the day it had been at seven.

I am not going to describe it. Everyone who needs to has seen it, and the people who lost someone that morning do not need it retold by a city guide on the Gulf coast. What I want to write about is smaller and closer and quieter. I want to write about the fence.

Every plant on the channel has one. It was there before that Tuesday and it is there now, but it is not the same fence, and the difference is the subject of this essay.

Before, a plant fence was mostly a property line with a gate in it. It kept cattle out and kids out and marked where the company's ground began. The guard at the gate knew the regulars by their trucks. A contractor with the right sticker rolled through. A delivery driver got waved on toward the warehouse. The gate was, in a practical sense, a formality, a place to slow down and nod. The real safety of the plant was inside it, in the procedures and the training and the instruments, and the fence was not thought of as part of that, or not much.

After, it was. Within a year or two, the federal government wrote new rules for the ports and the ships and the plants along the water, and a few years after that, new rules for chemical facilities specifically. A credential appeared that a worker on the waterfront had to carry, with a background check behind it and a fingerprint inside it. Gates that had been a nod became a checkpoint. Cameras went up along fence lines that had never had them. Vehicle barriers appeared. The perimeter of a plant, which had been a line on a survey, became a thing that people were paid to think about full time.

I am writing around the details on purpose, because the details are exactly the thing a plant does not publish, and it would be strange to write an essay about guarding a place and then describe how it is guarded. What I can say is what everybody who drives past can see. The fence is taller. The gate is slower. The badge does more.

It took me a long time, standing outside it, to understand why.

A refinery is not guarded because it is valuable, though it is. A car dealership is valuable. A bank is valuable. They have alarms and a night watchman and that is the end of it. A refinery is guarded because of what happens on the other side of it. The fuel in the airplane, the diesel in the truck that brings the groceries, the feedstock for the plastic in the hospital's tubing, the propane in the tank behind a house in Ohio. A barrel goes in at one end and comes apart, by heat, into its fractions, the light ones off the top and the heavy ones off the bottom, and each fraction leaves by a different pipe for a different life. The kerosene cut, the one that boils in the middle, is the one that flies. The plant is the beginning of a chain that runs out from the gate in every direction for thousands of miles, and a great many people at the far end of that chain have no idea it exists. That is what the fence is guarding. Not the tanks. The chain.

There is a kind of place in the world that carries more than its share of everybody else's life. A dam is one. A power plant is one. A water treatment works, a port, a bridge across a channel. The people who live next to those places know it in a way the rest of the country does not, because they can see the thing every day and the rest of the country can only see what it makes. Baytown is one of those places, and it has been since the refinery opened after the First World War, and the plants grew, and the channel filled with ships. The town has lived next to something the world depends on for a hundred years, and that is a weight more than a boast, carried the way anyone carries a thing for a hundred years, without mentioning it much.

After that Tuesday the weight got heavier, and the fence is the visible shape of it.

I think a lot about the people who work the gate, because they are the ones who carry the weight in the most literal sense, hour by hour. Their job, most of the time, is boring in the way that all guarding is boring. Check the badge. Look in the cab. Wave the truck on. Ten thousand trucks, a hundred thousand badges, and nothing happens, and nothing happening is the job. It is the same discipline the operator has on the tower. You watch a thing that is fine, and you keep watching it, and the watching is the work. A gauge that has read the same number for a month still gets read. A plant runs on people who take the absence of an event as seriously as an event.

There is an older idea in this. The word guard comes from the same root as the word ward, and warden, and regard, and it means, at the bottom, to look at. To watch. A guard is someone who looks at a thing on behalf of people who cannot. When the man at the gate looks in the cab of a truck, he is looking on behalf of a nurse in a city he will never visit, whose oxygen line was made from something that came through that gate. He does not think of it that way, and he should not have to. But it is true.

The town, too, watches. This is not something anyone organized. It is just what happens when people live next to a thing they understand. A refinery town knows what a flare means, knows the difference between a normal shift-change traffic jam and something wrong, knows the sound of the plant's sirens and what the different ones are for. In a town like this, thousands of people are looking at the fence every day without meaning to, and the looking is a kind of guarding too. The plant is inside the town's attention the way it is inside its economy.

I want to be careful not to make this into something it is not. The rules that came after that Tuesday were written in a hurry and in fear, and some of them fit the coast better than others, and there are people in the trades who have stood in the sun at a gate for an hour with a truck full of scaffold and a credential in their pocket and cursed the whole arrangement. That is fair. A fence costs something to the people on both sides of it. What I am saying is only that the fence is not arbitrary. It exists because of what the plant is for, and what the plant is for is everyone.

For two days after that morning, almost nothing flew over the country. People who lived under flight paths noticed the silence. Here, the plants on the coast that made the fuel those airplanes would have burned kept running, because a continuous process cannot simply pause, and because the fuel would be needed again as soon as the sky reopened. Somewhere in that week an operator on a night shift walked a unit under a sky with nothing in it, and the flare burned, and the tanks filled, and the chain from the gate to the rest of the world held its place, waiting.

It held. The world went on needing what the channel makes, and the channel went on making it, and a fence went up around the making that was taller than the one before.

On the anniversary, people here do what people everywhere do. A flag at half-staff over a fire station, as it is over every fire station in the country that morning. A moment of silence, in some classroom at Goose Creek Memorial or Sterling or Lee, for students who were not yet born on the Tuesday it happened and who know it the way I know the wars before my time, from people who were there. And then the day goes on, because the town has learned, over a hundred years, that going on is what it is for.

Every morning since that Tuesday has passed over the fence the same way, and the morning after the anniversary will too. The gate opens at five, before it is light. The headlights come in off the highway in a line that does not end. The guard leans out of the booth into the warm dark, checks the badge, looks in the cab, and waves the truck on.

En español

Hay una mañana de mediados de septiembre que casi todos los adultos pueden ubicar: saben dónde estaban, quién les avisó, qué radio sonaba en qué camioneta. Este ensayo no describe lo que pasó ese martes de 2001; eso ya lo vio quien lo necesitaba ver. Habla de algo más pequeño y más cercano: la cerca de la planta. Antes, la cerca de una refinería era casi una formalidad, donde el guardia saludaba a los de siempre. Después de ese día vinieron reglas federales para los puertos, los barcos y las plantas químicas, una credencial con huella digital, cámaras, barreras, y la entrada se volvió un punto de control. El ensayo explica por qué: una refinería no se cuida porque valga mucho, sino por lo que hay del otro lado de la cerca, la cadena que va desde la puerta hasta el combustible del avión, el diésel del camión de comida, el plástico de los tubos del hospital. Un pueblo como Baytown vive junto a algo de lo que depende el mundo, y eso es un peso, no una presunción. La palabra guardar viene de mirar, y el guardia en la puerta mira en nombre de gente que nunca conocerá. Termina en la puerta de la planta a las cinco de la mañana, con la fila de faros entrando y el guardia revisando el gafete, mirando la cabina, y dejando pasar el camión.

Read next

In the series

Places in this essay(1)